Mass Movements in Great Britain
Geological Conservation Review Series, No. 33
R G Cooper (ed)
Published by: Joint Nature Conservation Committee
Publication date: April, 2007
ISBN: 1-86107-481-6
List price: £45.00
348 pp
www.jncc.gov.uk
The Geological Conservation Review began publication in 1986 of a series of well-accepted volumes on British geoscience, reporting important national sites of special scientific interest (SSSI). This latest volume on mass movements was delayed by the untimely death of the main author and has been compiled with additions by a number of contributors and editors.
Following the overall remit of the series, the authors stress that the book follows a minimal approach to site selection by attempting to avoid repetition of similar landslide types in different areas. Whilst this approach is understandable, only 33 sites have been chosen with an obvious bias to inland slope failures in the Scottish Highlands (12 sites) and coastal landslides in southern England (7). This means that areas of England such as Pennines, Cotswolds and South Wales, which have some of the highest densities of landsliding (DoE Landslide Survey; Jones and Lee, 1994), are missed completely from the list.
The first chapter provides a well-structured and informative background, placing the different types of mass movement into spatial and temporal context with good definitions of landslide morphology and mechanisms. It also introduces the structure of the book, which is divided into eight chapters on the basis of bedrock geology, from Precambrian to Pleistocene. This interesting approach shows that all major rock units are represented in the list but only works to a limited degree because of distorted site distribution. Specific reports are well structured and informative and include well-known landslides such as Black Ven, Mam Tor and The Quiraing; plus some esoteric sites such as Lud’s Church (Staffordshire Moorlands) and Buckland’s Windypit (North Yorkshire). The volume maintains the high quality of the series with a good clear layout and excellent diagrams, although many panchromatic photographs lack sufficient contrast.
Given that landslides are important landscape elements, particularly in upland areas of Great Britain, and are an important hazard with social implications, this volume is too prescriptive in its selection of sites. It can be compared to the large number of Quaternary sites published in a series of regional volumes, which contain replicate scientific information. An opportunity has been missed to provide an overall assessment of British mass movements including representative examples from across the country.
Reference: Jones, D.K.C and Lee, M. 1994. Landslides in Great Britain. HMSO, 361pp
Wishart Mitchell, Department of Geography, University of Durham